Why I Was the Luckiest Student at Scripps College

My heart was beating and my mouth was dry. Dare I challenge my professor’s assertion that Marxism is a better economic system? As I began to speak, fifteen pairs of eyes turned my way…

Coming from a family of firm believers in the free market, I was never certain whether my opinions were my own or those of my parents. Leaving home, I looked forward to going to a college where I could encounter a range of viewpoints. Scripps gave me the perfect opportunity to challenge my most closely-held beliefs because I was on my own in a sea of people who disagreed with me. I went into my Core II class, “Eat the Rich! Capitalism and Work,” fully committed to evaluating alternative viewpoints.

I read the class materials with curiosity and an open mind, and I came to class prepared to discuss both sides of the issue. Unfortunately, I was the only one who voiced a capitalist perspective. If a class about capitalism does not address both the positives and negatives of the free market, students are not able to develop an informed opinion. While the professor claimed to address both sides of the issue, he rarely, if ever, presented the positive aspects of capitalism. Even more alarming was the fact that the socialist and Marxist readings were required, while the pro-capitalist readings were completely optional.

Now, back to that fateful moment. Overcoming my fears, I clearly stated my case. The professor scrambled for a response. That’s when I realized that I was the luckiest student at Scripps College. I am grateful to have been given the opportunity to challenge my own views, evaluate my long-held beliefs, and articulate my thoughts independently. I am especially grateful that I gained the confidence to stand my ground in a room full of people who disagreed with me. Other Scripps students, however, have not been so lucky in that respect.

As John Stuart Mill said, “He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that.” I challenge Scripps professors and students to explore all perspectives of an issue, so that every student can have the same opportunities that I have had.


Photography by Wes Edwards.

3 thoughts on “Why I Was the Luckiest Student at Scripps College”

  1. Good for you. Colleges are notable for attempting to control student thought from the front of the room, rather than providing opportunities to inform. Many instances of being given C(or worse) by a prof for a well-written and substantiated paper that does not agree with what he thinks.

  2. Most of the information we get growing up in the US is pro-capitalist, so who is really challenging their ideals? For every one of these anti-capitalist classes there are a multitude of other classes that are exclusively capitalist.

  3. Is “coming from a family of firm believers in the free market” code for “Coming from a rich family who benefits from the free market, while others starve under its burden…”? Because that’s what I read.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *